Press
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

PensionBee calls for ban on flat fees on pension pots below £5,000 to stop small pot erosion

Press
17
Nov 2026
Press

PensionBee warns millions of savers risk having their pensions moved without their consent, while small pots continue to be eroded by excessive charges, and is calling for policy changes to:

  • Ban flat fees on pension pots worth less than £5,000, preventing charges from disproportionately eroding the value of smaller pension savings.
  • Put Pensions Dashboards first, giving savers time to find lost and forgotten pots and consolidate them voluntarily before the Government considers whether automatic consolidation is necessary.
  • Make automatic consolidation opt-in, not opt-out, ensuring savers engage, choose where their money goes, and are asked for consent each time a pension pot becomes eligible for transfer. Alongside this, the government should allow personal pension providers to participate alongside workplace providers.
  • Make pension charges clearer and easier to compare, requiring providers to show the true cost in pounds and pence, alongside the annual charge as a percentage of the pot and a prominent Value for Money rating.

London, 17 November 2026: Complex and opaque charging structures, which include flat fees applied to small pension pots, can swallow up as much as 16% of a £150 pension pot in a year, prompting calls for the Government to ban the charges on smaller pension pots (worth less than £5,000) and rethink current proposals to automatically consolidate millions of smaller pension pots.

In its response to the Department for Work and Pensions' (DWP) consultation on Small Pots: a pathway for consolidation, PensionBee has warned that the proposed mechanism for automatically transferring dormant pension pots into workplace schemes chosen on a saver’s behalf and without their consent, without addressing the underlying problem of excessive charges - risks undermining consumer choice and causing consumer confusion, and does not necessarily prioritise better retirement outcomes. 

The DWP's proposals would seek to introduce a Multiple Default Consolidator system from 2030, automatically transferring eligible deferred pension pots into authorised consolidator schemes. The policy aims to address the growing number of small, inactive pensions left behind when people change jobs, automatically consolidating pots worth £1,000 or less that have received no contributions for 12 months. The Government estimates around 20 million pots will be in scope when the scheme starts. 

Flat fees can swallow up growth in the smallest pension pots

Currently, flat fees can be charged on pension pots in defined contribution auto-enrollment qualifying workplace default arrangements that are worth more than the £100 de minimis threshold. However, because flat fees can be applied (on top of percentage fees) to pots that are above this amount but are still ‘small’, they can quickly erode what little is in the pension. 

PensionBee’s analysis of published pension scheme charges at some of the UK’s largest master trusts found that a deferred £150 pension pot can face annual charges equivalent to 16% of its value - a result of flat fees in combination with a percentage charge applied to the pot’s value. Charges can account for up to 9.9% of a £250 pension pot, up to 5.1% of a £500 pot, up to 2.8% of a £1,000 pot, and up to 0.9% of a £5,000 pot, depending on the scheme. 

PensionBee’s modelling also shows that a £500 pot left with one of these providers would be worth slightly less after 10 years of 5% annual investment growth than when it started. The same pot with no flat fee would grow to around £790. 

Automatic consolidation risks moving savers' money without their consent

PensionBee is clear that the £1,000 threshold for automatic consolidation should not be raised, but it is proposing a £5,000 de minimis threshold for small pots, under which flat fees charged by relevant consolidator schemes should be banned.

It also argues that the proposals could see savers' money moved to unfamiliar providers, leaving them with additional accounts, logins and apps to navigate, without the safeguards that ensure moves will mean better value for money, and doing nothing to stop the charges that erode small pots in the meantime. Flat fees are also rising: one major scheme increased its annual fixed charge by 44% earlier this year. 

The consultation response calls on the Government to take a ‘watch and learn’ approach, giving savers several years to use the MoneyHelper Pensions Dashboard to identify and voluntarily consolidate their pensions before deciding whether automatic consolidation is necessary. The Dashboard should then offer an opt-in facility for savers, allowing them to choose if and where their pensions are transferred to, and retain control each time a pot becomes eligible. 

A need for greater transparency over pension charges

PensionBee is also calling for providers to show the true cost of holding a pension in pounds and pence, alongside the annual charge as a percentage of the pension pot value, surfaced with a prominent Value for Money rating, to help savers understand what they are paying. The need for greater transparency is clear, with the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) Financial Lives Survey finding that 57% of adults with a defined contribution pension do not know they pay fees at all.  

The call comes as the FCA consults on exempting performance fees from the workplace pensions charge cap for contract-based schemes (0.75%), to support investment in private markets, following a similar change for trust-based schemes in 2023. PensionBee argues that if the cap is being loosened for some costs, savers with the smallest pots need protection from the flat fees that cost them most, more than ever. 

Lisa Picardo, Chief Business Officer UK at PensionBee, said: “Automatically consolidating millions of people's pension pots without their consent is not the answer to the small pots problem. It risks taking away choice, control and agency over where retirement savings are held and how they are managed, moving people's money into unfamiliar schemes, and creating further confusion through additional accounts, logins and apps. 

“These proposals may be convenient for the pensions industry, which sees workplace increasingly dominated by a small number of large schemes, but they should be designed with the consumer front and centre. They will not solve better consumer outcomes unless the right protections and guardrails are first in place.

“Crucially, the proposals do not address the underlying problem of excessive charges eroding the value of small pension pots. The Government should tackle the problem at its source by introducing a £5,000 de minimis threshold, banning flat fees on pension pots below this level. Even worse, many people who hold small deferred workplace pension pots will be completely unaware of the charges and damaging pot-erosion dynamics at play. Providers should be required to show members the true cost of holding a pension in pounds and pence, and expressed as a percentage of pot value. 

“Rather than automatically deciding where people's money should go, the Government should give savers the visibility, information and tools to support them in making decisions for themselves. We know that where savers are more engaged, they stand a better chance of improving their retirement outcome.  

“The MoneyHelper Pensions Dashboard, a decade in the making, will finally provide a natural opportunity to put savers in control - reuniting them with lost and forgotten pots, allowing them to view all their pensions in one place. Once live, the Government should watch and learn, allowing savers to voluntarily consolidate, before deciding whether automatic consolidation is necessary. The Dashboard should then offer an opt-in facility for savers, allowing them to choose if they want to consolidate, and to what destination - opening up to personal pension providers as well as workplace providers, allowing the saver to retain control each time a pot becomes eligible. Future versions of the Dashboard could surface key information to support decision-making such as how money is invested, the real cost, and its Value for Money rating.

“Moving pension money around is not the same as delivering better outcomes for savers. If the Government wants to improve retirement outcomes, it must start by making pensions fairer and more transparent for savers, and build a system that champions engagement over reliance on inertia.”

Recent Press & Award articles
Have a question?
Call our UK team
Monday-Friday: 9:30am-5pm