New research from PensionBee finds that 42% of savers who have previously tried to change pension providers, feel that the process was so difficult that they would not attempt another transfer. Many savers also reported issues accessing support from their providers during the transfer process, with more than half (51%) citing some kind of difficulty, from long waiting times (22%) to giving up after multiple failed attempts (9%).
In addition, 50% of savers who attempted to transfer a defined contribution pension were still required to complete paperwork, with more than a quarter (27%) having to complete multiple sets of forms. This is despite electronic transfers being widely recognised as much faster, more efficient and secure for consumers than traditional paper-based methods.
Slow, difficult transfers have been an issue for many years. In 2016 the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) asked the pensions industry to speed up transfers for the benefit of savers and a number of working groups, like TRIG and STAR, were formed. However, recent data published by Origo Options, the pension transfer service, showed that five years after this process began transfer times are in fact slowing down.
PensionBee’s own data reveals a series of slow transfer offenders, with Mercer at an average of 46 days to transfer and NOW: Pensions (44 days) and Capita (40 days) not far behind.
PensionBee CEO, Romi Savova, comments: “Long and complex processes deter people from engaging with their pensions and switching when it may be in their best interests to do so. Low levels of digitisation exacerbate chronic under-saving because people don’t have the right tools and information to understand the importance of planning ahead for their financial future. Technology provides an opportunity for the industry to better engage savers, and it’s time for pensions to make their way into the 21st century with a simple, modern pension switch guarantee.”
Appendix
Table 1: Transfer difficulty
| My previous pension transfer experiences have been difficult and I would not attempt another | Proportion of respondents |
|---|---|
| Strongly agree | 17% |
| Agree | 25% |
| Neither agree nor disagree | 20% |
| Disagree | 24% |
| Strongly disagree | 14% |
Source: PensionBee, July 2021. 428 respondents. Numbers have been rounded.
Table 2: Accessing support during the transfer process
| How easy was it to get support by phone, email, or Live Chat from your old provider? | Proportion of respondents |
|---|---|
| Easy, I tried and got support at first attempt within a reasonable timeframe | 26% |
| I’ve never felt the need to seek support from my provider | 22% |
| Fairly easy, I tried and got support at first attempt but with a long waiting time | 22% |
| Hard, it took multiple attempts to get support | 10% |
| Very hard, despite multiple attempts, I didn’t get support | 9% |
| Hard, I tried once and gave up | 6% |
| I failed to get support from my pension provider as I couldn’t find their contact details | 5% |
| Other | 1% |
Source: PensionBee, July 2021. 424 respondents. Numbers have been rounded.
Table 3: Transfer process
| How was the process of changing pension providers managed? | Proportion of respondents |
|---|---|
| It was all online | 41% |
| There were multiple sets of paperwork | 27% |
| There was one set of paperwork | 23% |
| I can’t remember | 8% |
| Other | 1% |
Source: PensionBee, July 2021. 429 respondents. Numbers have been rounded.
Table 4: Slowest providers for pension transfers
| Provider name | Average number of days to transfer |
|---|---|
| Hargreaves Lansdown | 48 |
| Mercer | 46 |
| NOW: Pensions | 44 |
| Capita | 40 |
Source: PensionBee, July 2021.
