10 Retirement Plan Compliance Best Practices

Summary

Explore 10 ERISA fiduciary best practices to reduce compliance risk and manage small, inactive participant balances.

Key Takeaways

Addressing small, inactive participant accounts early can help simplify plan administration and reduce potential compliance challenges.
Regular reviews of terminated participant balances and accurate recordkeeping can help prevent missing participant issues.
SECURE 2.0 allows plans to increase the automatic rollover threshold from $5,000 to $7,000, providing more flexibility for managing small account balances.
Automatic rollovers can help streamline plan administration while keeping eligible participants’ retirement savings in a tax-advantaged account.
Prudent provider selection, ongoing monitoring, and thorough documentation are essential components of an effective automatic rollover program.

‍

Meeting ERISA fiduciary responsibility standards requires more than following plan documents. It means proactively managing operational risks like small, inactive participant accounts before they become compliance liabilities. These 10 best practices address the day-to-day administrative and fiduciary obligations that most often create risk for plan sponsors and advisors.

Keeping a retirement plan compliant and running smoothly requires ongoing attention to both regulatory obligations and day-to-day operations. One area that often goes overlooked is the accumulation of small account balances left behind by former employees. These accounts can linger for years, increase administrative responsibilities, and create additional fiduciary considerations.

By proactively addressing dormant balances through automatic rollover programs and Safe Harbor IRAs, plan sponsors and advisors can simplify plan administration, support fiduciary compliance, and help participants remain connected to their retirement savings.

Why Do Small-Balance Accounts Create Retirement Plan Compliance Risk?

Former employees frequently leave retirement savings behind when changing jobs. As these accounts accumulate, plan sponsors remain responsible for maintaining records, delivering required notices, and administering benefits in accordance with plan terms.

Potential Challenges Created by Dormant Accounts

Risk Area	Impact
Administrative burden	Requires additional recordkeeping, participant communications, compliance tracking, and audit support.
Fees and expenses	May increase plan costs as additional administration and servicing are required for small, inactive account balances.
Missing participants	Creates potential fiduciary concerns if participant searches, documentation, and account tracking processes are not properly maintained.
Fraud/communication risk	Outdated contact information, low participant engagement, and uncashed checks can make account management more difficult.
Plan termination delays	Unresolved small balances or missing participants can delay plan termination, final distributions, and audit completion.

1. Establish Strong Fiduciary Oversight

Effective retirement plan management starts with a clear understanding of fiduciary responsibilities. Plan sponsors should ensure fiduciary committee members understand their roles, establish documented processes, and regularly evaluate whether plan operations align with regulatory requirements and participant needs.

Strong fiduciary oversight can help reduce operational risks, support better decision-making, and enhance the overall effectiveness of the retirement plan.

2. Regularly Review Terminated Participant Balances

Former employees who leave retirement savings behind can create ongoing challenges, particularly when small balances remain in the plan for extended periods.

Conducting periodic reviews of terminated participant accounts can help sponsors identify inactive balances, evaluate existing distribution practices, and address potential issues before they become larger administrative or compliance concerns. For plans with higher turnover, proactively managing these accounts can support more efficient plan operations over time.

3. Maintain Accurate Participant Records

Keeping participant information current is essential for effective plan administration and communication.

Sponsors should collect updated contact information, including mailing addresses, email addresses, and beneficiary details, throughout the employee lifecycle, particularly at termination. Strong recordkeeping practices can reduce the likelihood of participants becoming difficult to locate and facilitate future distribution processing.

4. Review and Update Distribution Policies

Distribution provisions should be reviewed periodically to ensure they continue to align with plan operations, participant needs, and regulatory requirements.

Under SECURE 2.0, plans may increase the automatic rollover threshold for certain terminated participants with small account balances from $5,000 to $7,000. This expanded flexibility allows eligible plans to address a larger number of small inactive accounts through automatic rollovers, helping improve operational efficiency while keeping retirement assets in a tax-advantaged environment.

Sponsors should also confirm that plan documents, participant communications, and administrative procedures reflect any updated distribution provisions.

Managing terminated participants with small balances?

PensionBee works with advisors and plan sponsors to process automatic rollovers end-to-end, with fiduciary documentation.

Talk to our team

5. Use Automatic Rollovers to Manage Small Inactive Accounts

Automatic rollovers can be an effective strategy for addressing small terminated participant balances. Rather than leaving these accounts in the plan indefinitely, eligible balances may be transferred to a Safe Harbor IRA, providing plan sponsors with a structured process for handling certain inactive accounts and reducing the long-term oversight associated with maintaining small balances within the plan.

The potential administrative and fiduciary considerations associated with automatic rollovers are outlined below.

Area	Impact on Advisors and Plan Sponsors
Plan Administration	Fewer dormant accounts remain in the plan.
Participant Retention	Reduced the likelihood of small-balance cash-outs.
Fiduciary Oversight	Greater emphasis on prudent provider selection.
Compliance	Increased importance of notices and documentation.
Operational Efficiency	Streamlined management of terminated participants.

6. Prudently Select Automatic Rollover Providers

Implementing an automatic rollover program begins with selecting service providers that can effectively support the plan's objectives and participant needs. Because provider selection is itself a fiduciary responsibility, sponsors should conduct appropriate due diligence before establishing a rollover arrangement.

In performing this due diligence, sponsors may evaluate factors such as:

Experience serving retirement plans of similar size and complexity
Fee structures and overall cost transparency
Investment approaches for Safe Harbor IRA assets
Participant communication and account servicing capabilities
Cybersecurity practices and data protection measures
Fiduciary liability coverage and industry track record

‍

Documenting the selection process can help demonstrate that fiduciaries have taken a prudent approach when implementing an automatic rollover solution.

7. Monitor Providers on an Ongoing Basis

Selecting a provider is only the beginning. Plan sponsors should establish a process for periodically monitoring service providers to ensure they continue to meet the plan's needs and fulfill their responsibilities effectively.

Ongoing reviews may include:

Reviewing service performance and participant support
Evaluating fee reasonableness over time
Assessing any changes to services, compensation, or business practices
Reviewing participant feedback and complaints
Monitoring cybersecurity practices and operational capabilities
Confirming that automatic rollover and missing participant services continue to function effectively

‍

Regular monitoring helps demonstrate prudent fiduciary oversight and allows sponsors to determine whether existing providers remain appropriate as plan needs evolve.

8. Review Plan Costs and Administrative Efficiency

Small inactive balances can have cost implications that are not always immediately apparent. Additional recordkeeping, participant communications, search efforts, and ongoing oversight may increase the resources required to administer the plan over time.

Sponsors should periodically evaluate plan expenses, service arrangements, and administrative processes to identify opportunities for improvement. In some cases, reducing unnecessary inactive accounts through automatic rollovers may help create a more efficient and cost-effective plan structure.

9. Ensure Plan Practices Match Plan Documents

A retirement plan's procedures should consistently reflect the terms of its governing documents.

Sponsors should periodically review plan documents, summary plan descriptions, and administrative procedures to ensure plan operations remain consistent with written plan provisions, particularly following changes to distribution practices or rollover policies. This alignment can help reduce operational and compliance risks.

10. Document Fiduciary Processes and Decisions

Maintaining records of committee discussions, provider evaluations, fee reviews, and decisions related to automatic rollover programs can help demonstrate a prudent fiduciary process. Thorough documentation also supports consistency in plan administration and may prove valuable during regulatory examinations or audits.

Keep Your Plan Compliant and Effective with Automatic Rollovers

Keeping a retirement plan compliant and effective requires more than simply meeting regulatory requirements. It also involves proactively identifying operational challenges that can increase costs and create fiduciary risk over time. Small balances left behind by terminated employees are one such challenge.

PensionBee’s automatic rollover IRA solution supports this by handling distributions end-to-end. It moves eligible balances out of retirement plans into an IRA in a compliant and streamlined way, helping reduce administrative burden for plan sponsors while improving plan health. For advisors, it also provides a practical solution to stranded or inactive accounts that often surface during plan reviews or termination events

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is a Safe Harbor IRA?

A Safe Harbor IRA is an individual retirement account used to receive distributions from retirement plans for terminated employees with small account balances (under $7,000). Under ERISA and SECURE 2.0, plan sponsors have the option to roll these balances into Safe Harbor IRAs rather than distributing them as cash.

Is rolling balances into a Safe Harbor IRA mandatory?

No. It depends on whether the plan includes a force-out provision. Plans are not required to have one. However, plans that do must administer it consistently, in compliance with DOL Reg. 2550.404a-2, with a qualified provider selection process in place.

What did SECURE 2.0 change about automatic rollovers?

SECURE 2.0 (Section 304) raised the involuntary cash-out limit from $5,000 to $7,000, effective for distributions made after December 31, 2023. This means plan sponsors can now process distributions for terminated participants with vested balances up to $7,000.

When do force-out rules apply?

Force-out rules apply when a terminated participant's vested balance falls between $1,000 and $7,000, and the participant does not make an affirmative election about where the funds should go. Under DOL Reg. 2550.404a-2, those balances must be rolled into a Safe Harbor IRA. Balances under $1,000 may be distributed as cash.

Why does participant offboarding matter in retirement plans?

The offboarding process is a critical moment where participants make decisions about their retirement savings. Poor communication or lack of guidance can lead to cash-outs, potentially resulting in retirement leakage or reduced long-term outcomes.

Who is subject to ERISA?

ERISA generally applies to private-sector retirement plans. It does not cover government or church plans, plans solely for workers’ compensation/unemployment/disability, unfunded deferred compensation (“top-hat”) plans, or individually established IRAs.

What are the core fiduciary duties under ERISA?

The core fiduciary duties under ERISA are:

Duty of Loyalty: Act solely in the interest of participants and beneficiaries, avoiding self-interest and focusing on providing plan benefits while paying only reasonable expenses.
Duty of Prudence: Exercise care, skill, and diligence a prudent person would use in similar circumstances, including both selecting and monitoring investments.
Duty to Diversify Investments: Reduce the risk of large losses by diversifying plan assets, unless non-diversification is clearly prudent.
Duty to Follow Plan Documents: Comply with plan rules, as long as they align with ERISA requirements.

What are the basic ERISA requirements for plan sponsors?

ERISA sets minimum standards for retirement and health plans, including providing participants with key plan information, establishing rules for participation, vesting, benefit accrual, and funding, and imposing fiduciary duties on those who manage plan assets. It also requires a claims and appeals process, gives participants the right to sue for benefits and fiduciary breaches, and provides PBGC protection for certain defined benefit plans.

How should plan sponsors evaluate automatic rollover IRA providers?

Sponsors should compare fees (including annual maintenance and any transfer-out charges), yields or interest rates, capital preservation features, and the quality of participant communications. The selection process should be documented, and the provider should be reviewed on a recurring basis. Failing to do this can result in participants being defaulted into accounts that don't serve their long-term interests, which creates its own fiduciary risk.

What are the fee requirements under ERISA?

All plan-related fees, recordkeeping, investment management, and advisory must be disclosed clearly and be reasonable relative to the services provided.

What happens if a plan fails ERISA compliance?

Non-compliance can result in DOL investigations, excise taxes, prohibited transaction penalties, participant lawsuits, and in severe cases, plan disqualification. The most common triggers are fee-related lawsuits, inadequate documentation, and mishandled distributions for terminated employees.

What role does compliance play in rollovers?

Compliance plays an important role in rollover execution. Rollovers must follow IRS rules and plan provisions to maintain tax-advantaged status and avoid unintended taxable distributions. Direct rollovers can help reduce the risk of errors during the transfer process, though results may vary by provider. Documenting the rollover rationale, plan comparison, and participant communication is a best practice and helps show the decision was made in the participant’s best interest if it is reviewed.

Is compliance enough to ensure a well-run retirement plan?

No. While compliance is essential, it does not ensure effective plan governance or administrative efficiency. Effective plan management requires ongoing evaluation of fees, service providers, and operational processes.

Disclaimer

Investing involves risk.‍ This post, and any associated customer testimonial or third party endorsement, is provided solely for informational and educational purposes, should not be taken as tax, legal, financial or investment advice and is not an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy or sell any securities or investments

The Problem with Automatic Rollovers

ERISA Fiduciary Responsibility: 10 Retirement Plan Compliance Best Practices

Page content